Chapter 1
Slicing a cone
Take two ice-cream cones and join them tip to tip, so they open up and down forever. Mathematicians call this a double cone. Now cut it with a flat plane.
The edge of the cut is a curve, and there are only four kinds of answer. If the plane is level, you get a circle. Tilt it a little and the circle stretches into an ellipse. Tilt it until it is exactly as steep as the side of the cone and the curve never closes: it becomes a parabola. Tilt it further and the plane cuts both cones, giving a hyperbola with two separate branches.
Apollonius of Perga wrote eight books about these curves around 200 BCE and gave them the names we still use. Together they are called the conic sections.
One number decides the shape
If the side of the cone makes an angle α with the axis and the plane is tilted by β from level, the shape is fixed by the eccentricity
e = 0 is a circle, 0 < e < 1 an ellipse, e = 1 a parabola, e > 1 a hyperbola. Moving the plane up or down changes the size of the curve, but not its shape. If the plane passes right through the tip, the cut collapses to a point or to straight lines: these are the degenerate conics.
Why does a slanted cut of a round cone give an ellipse, with its two special points called foci? In 1822 Germinal Dandelin found a beautiful proof. Drop two balls into the cone, one above and one below the plane, each just touching the cone all the way round and touching the plane at one point. Those two touching points are exactly the foci. We meet the foci in the next chapter.
Chapter 2
Two ways to draw a conic without a cone
The gardener's ellipse
Push two pins into a board, tie a loop of string around them, and pull it tight with a pencil. As the pencil moves, the two pieces of string change length, but their total stays the same. The curve you draw is an ellipse, and the pins are its foci (Latin for "fireplaces"; Kepler chose the word because the Sun sits at one of them).
Here a is the semi-major axis, half the longest width. Gardeners really do mark out oval flower beds this way.
Focus and directrix: one rule for all four curves
The string trick only works for ellipses. A rule that covers every conic uses one focus F and a straight line D called the directrix. A point P lies on the conic when its distance to the focus is e times its distance to the line:
With e = 1 the point is equally far from both: a parabola. With e < 1 it stays closer to the focus and wraps around it: an ellipse. With e > 1 it can run off to infinity in two directions: a hyperbola. Try it below.
Chapter 3
The equations, step by step
René Descartes and Pierre de Fermat showed in the 1630s that curves can be written as equations in x and y. Every conic turns out to be a curve of degree two: its equation has x2, xy or y2 in it, and nothing higher.
The ellipse from the string rule
Put the centre at the origin and the foci at (−c, 0) and (c, 0). The string rule says
- Write the rule: √((x+c)² + y²) + √((x−c)² + y²) = 2a.
- Move one root across and square both sides. Most terms cancel and you are left with a√((x−c)² + y²) = a² − cx.
- Square again and tidy up: (a² − c²)x² + a²y² = a²(a² − c²).
- Call b² = a² − c² and divide by a²b².
The number b is the semi-minor axis, half the shortest width. When c = 0 the foci meet, a = b, and the ellipse is a circle of radius a. The area of the ellipse is πab, which we will need for Kepler's second law.
| Curve | Standard equation | Eccentricity | Foci |
|---|---|---|---|
| Circle | x² + y² = r² | e = 0 | both at the centre |
| Ellipse | x²/a² + y²/b² = 1 | e = √(1 − b²/a²) | (±c, 0), c² = a² − b² |
| Parabola | y² = 4fx | e = 1 | (f, 0); directrix x = −f |
| Hyperbola | x²/a² − y²/b² = 1 | e = √(1 + b²/a²) | (±c, 0), c² = a² + b² |
The polar equation: the one astronomers use
For orbits it is better to measure from the focus, where the Sun is. Use the distance r from the focus and the angle θ from the closest point. Put the directrix at distance d from the focus. The focus–directrix rule gives:
- Distance to the focus: r. Distance to the directrix: d − r cos θ.
- The rule |PF| = e|PD| becomes r = e(d − r cos θ).
- Collect the r terms: r(1 + e cos θ) = ed.
One formula, all four curves. For an ellipse, p = a(1 − e²). The closest point (θ = 0) is at r = a(1 − e) and the farthest (θ = 180°) at r = a(1 + e). For a planet these are called perihelion and aphelion, from the Greek for "near the Sun" and "away from the Sun".
Chapter 4
Mirrors shaped like conics
Conics have a famous reflection property. A ray of light (or sound) leaving one focus of an elliptical mirror always bounces through the other focus. A parabolic mirror sends every ray that arrives parallel to its axis to the single focus, which is why it is called a focus: it is where sunlight would set paper on fire.
Chapter 5
From perfect circles to ellipses
For two thousand years, astronomers believed the heavens were made of perfect circles. The trouble was that the planets do not seem to move in circles. Mars sometimes slows down, stops, goes backwards for a few weeks, then carries on. To explain this, astronomers stacked circles on circles.
- c. 150 CE. Claudius Ptolemy puts the Earth at the centre. Each planet rides a small circle (an epicycle) whose centre rides a large circle. His tables work well enough to be used for 1,400 years.
- 1543. Nicolaus Copernicus puts the Sun at the centre. The backwards loops of Mars now have a simple reason: the faster Earth overtakes it. But he still uses circles, and still needs epicycles.
- 1576–1597. Tycho Brahe, on his island observatory of Uraniborg, measures planet positions to about 2 arcminutes, without a telescope. An arcminute is 1/60 of a degree: a coin seen from 80 metres away.
- 1596. A young Johannes Kepler publishes Mysterium Cosmographicum. He fits the five Platonic solids between the spheres of the six known planets. It is beautiful and wrong, but it makes him determined to find the true design.
- 1600–1605. Kepler joins Tycho in Prague and inherits his data. He spends years on the orbit of Mars. His best circle misses Tycho's positions by 8 arcminutes. Kepler refused to ignore them. He later wrote that these eight minutes alone led the way to a complete reform of astronomy.
- 1609. Astronomia Nova: Mars moves on an ellipse with the Sun at one focus, and sweeps out equal areas in equal times. These are Kepler's first two laws.
- 1619. Harmonices Mundi: the third law, linking each planet's period to its distance.
- 1687. Isaac Newton's Principia shows that one force, gravity falling off as 1/r2, explains all three laws, and that every orbit must be a conic section.
You can redo Kepler's work in the game Kepler the detective: fit an orbit to observations of Mars and see whether you can get under his 8 arcminutes.
Chapter 6
First law: orbits are ellipses
Kepler's first law. Every planet moves on an ellipse, with the Sun at one focus. The other focus is empty.
Real planetary orbits are very close to circles. The eccentricity of Earth's orbit is 0.017, so its minor axis is only 0.014% shorter than its major axis: far too little to see in a drawing. What you can see is that the Sun is not at the centre. Earth is about 5 million km closer to the Sun in early January than in early July.
| Body | a (AU) | e | b/a | Perihelion (AU) | Aphelion (AU) |
|---|
1 AU (astronomical unit) is the average Earth–Sun distance, about 149.6 million km. Perihelion is a(1 − e) and aphelion is a(1 + e).
Chapter 7
Second law: equal areas in equal times
Kepler's second law. The line from the Sun to a planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times.
Near the Sun the line is short, so the planet must move faster to cover the same area. Far from the Sun it moves slowly. The ratio of the fastest to the slowest speed is (1 + e) / (1 − e). For Earth that is only 1.03, but it is enough to make northern winter about five days shorter than northern summer.
Where is the planet at a given time? Kepler's equation
The second law tells us how fast the area grows, but not directly where the planet is. Kepler solved this with three angles, all measured from perihelion:
- The mean anomaly M grows at a steady rate: M = 2π(t − tp)/T, where T is the period and tp the time of perihelion.
- The eccentric anomaly E is the angle of the matching point on the circle drawn around the ellipse.
- The true anomaly θ is the actual angle of the planet seen from the Sun.
The area swept since perihelion is a fraction M/2π of the whole ellipse. Working that area out geometrically gives Kepler's equation, and from E you get the position:
There is no formula that gives E directly from M. You must solve it by trying. Newton's method converges very fast: start from E0 = M and repeat
Try it: solve Kepler's equation
| Step | E (degrees) | Error E − e sin E − M |
|---|
Why equal areas? A first look at the physics
In a short time dt the planet moves through a small angle dθ, sweeping a thin triangle of area ½r²dθ. So the rate of sweeping is ½r²(dθ/dt). Newton showed that this is half the planet's angular momentum per unit mass, which stays constant whenever the force points straight at the Sun. So the second law holds for any force directed at the Sun, not only gravity.
Chapter 8
Third law: the harmony of the worlds
Kepler's third law. The square of a planet's period is proportional to the cube of its semi-major axis: T² ∝ a³. Measured in years and astronomical units, T² = a³.
Kepler looked for a rule like this for over twenty years and found it in 1618. Plotted on ordinary axes the points curve upwards. On a log–log plot, where each step along an axis multiplies by ten, they fall on a straight line of slope 3/2, because log T = (3/2) log a.
| Body | a (AU) | T (years) | T² | a³ | T² ÷ a³ |
|---|
Where the third law comes from
Take a planet of mass m on a circle of radius r around a Sun of mass M. Gravity supplies the force that keeps it turning:
- Gravity: F = GMm/r². Force needed to move in a circle at speed v: mv²/r.
- Set them equal: v² = GM/r.
- One lap takes T = 2πr/v, so T² = 4π²r²/v² = (4π²/GM) r³.
For ellipses the same formula holds with a the semi-major axis. The constant depends only on the mass of the central body. That is how astronomers weigh things they cannot touch: time a moon around a planet, measure its distance, and solve for M. It is also how we know the mass of the black hole at the centre of our galaxy, from stars orbiting it.
Chapter 9
Newton's why: a cannon on a mountain
Kepler described how planets move. Newton explained why. In his Principia he imagined a cannon on a very high mountain, firing horizontally. Fire slowly and the ball falls to the ground. Fire faster and it lands further away, because the Earth curves away beneath it. Fire fast enough and the ground curves away exactly as fast as the ball falls: it never lands. It is in orbit.
Newton proved that under a force proportional to 1/r², the path is always a conic section with the centre of force at a focus. Which conic depends on the energy. Per unit mass:
For a closed orbit ε = −GM/(2a), which gives the vis-viva equation for the speed anywhere on the orbit, and the two famous speeds:
Challenges
- Land on the far side of the Earth
- Make a circular orbit (e < 0.01)
- Make an ellipse that climbs above 3 Earth radii
- Escape from the Earth forever
Chapter 10
Games
Three games that use everything above. The first is quick. The second is Kepler's own problem. The third is a real mission planner's problem.
Game 1: Name that conic
Ten questions: equations, eccentricities, pictures and a few about the sky. Answer fast for a streak bonus.
Game 2: Kepler the detective
Below are twelve positions of Mars as seen from the Sun, with their dates, like the ones Kepler took from Tycho's notebooks. Mars's period is known: 1.881 years. Your job is to find its orbit. Choose the eccentricity, the direction of perihelion and the date of perihelion. For each observation the game uses Kepler's equation to work out where your orbit puts Mars on that date, and measures the error as an angle seen from the Sun.
A circle (e = 0) can never do better than several degrees. Kepler's target was Tycho's accuracy: under 8 arcminutes for every observation.
Error for each observation
Game 3: Mission to Mars
Your spacecraft starts in Earth's orbit. Fire the engine once, forwards or backwards, and you change your orbit into an ellipse around the Sun. Too little and you never reach your target's orbit. And even with the right ellipse, the planet must be there when you arrive.
The cheapest route is the Hohmann transfer (Walter Hohmann, 1925): an ellipse that just touches both orbits. By the third law, the trip to Mars then takes half the period of that ellipse, about 259 days, so you must launch when Mars is about 44° ahead of Earth. Choose your burn, watch the angle, and press Launch at the right moment.
Chapter 11
Conic sections today
Kepler's laws work for anything orbiting anything: moons around planets, satellites around Earth, planets around other stars. And the reflection properties of conics are built into everyday technology.
Satellites
The geostationary orbit
A satellite that circles once per sidereal day (86,164 s) stays above the same spot on the equator. The third law with Earth's GM = 398,600 km³/s² gives a = (GM T²/4π²)1/3 ≈ 42,164 km from Earth's centre, about 35,786 km above the surface. Weather and TV satellites live there.
Navigation
GPS
GPS satellites move on near-circular orbits with a period of half a sidereal day, so by the third law their orbit radius is 2−2/3 times the geostationary one, about 26,560 km. Your receiver needs to know exactly where each one is, and it uses Kepler's equation to compute that.
Space travel
Transfer orbits and slingshots
Missions to Mars follow ellipses close to the Hohmann transfer of Game 3. Launch windows open every 26 months, when Earth and Mars line up again. Close flybys of planets follow hyperbolas relative to the planet, which can bend a spacecraft's path and change its speed for free.
Comets
Halley and visitors from other stars
Edmond Halley used Newton's theory to show that the comets of 1531, 1607 and 1682 were one object on an ellipse, and predicted its return in 1758. In 2017, 'Oumuamua passed through the Solar System on a hyperbola with e ≈ 1.2: the first known visitor from another star.
Exoplanets
Weighing other worlds
When a planet passes in front of its star, the star dims a little once per orbit. The time between dips is the period T; with the star's mass, the third law gives the orbit size. NASA's Kepler space telescope found thousands of planets this way.
Telescopes and dishes
Parabolic mirrors
Starlight arrives as parallel rays. A parabolic mirror brings them all to one focus. Satellite dishes, radio telescopes and solar furnaces use the same shape, and car headlights use it backwards: a bulb at the focus makes a parallel beam.
Medicine
Breaking kidney stones
In lithotripsy, a shock wave is made at one focus of an ellipsoidal reflector. The reflector focuses it at the other focus, placed on the kidney stone, which breaks into pieces without surgery.
Architecture
Whispering galleries
In a room with an elliptical ceiling, a whisper at one focus can be heard clearly at the other. The old House of Representatives chamber in the US Capitol, now Statuary Hall, is a famous example.
Navigation and engineering
Hyperbolas
Points where the difference of distances to two radio stations is constant lie on a hyperbola, which systems like LORAN used to find ships. Cooling towers are hyperboloids: strong, and built from straight beams.
Chapter 12
Summary of the mathematics
| Conic section | The curve where a plane cuts a double cone: circle, ellipse, parabola or hyperbola. |
| Eccentricity | e decides the shape: 0 circle, between 0 and 1 ellipse, 1 parabola, above 1 hyperbola. |
| Focus–directrix rule | |PF| = e · |PD| |
| Ellipse | x²/a² + y²/b² = 1, c² = a² − b², e = c/a, area πab |
| Polar form | r = p/(1 + e cos θ), p = a(1 − e²) |
| Perihelion, aphelion | a(1 − e), a(1 + e) |
| First law | Orbits are ellipses with the Sun at one focus. |
| Second law | Equal areas in equal times; r² dθ/dt is constant. |
| Kepler's equation | M = E − e sin E |
| Third law | T² = (4π²/GM) a³; in years and AU, T² = a³ |
| Vis-viva | v² = GM(2/r − 1/a) |
| Energy and shape | Negative energy: ellipse. Zero: parabola. Positive: hyperbola. Escape speed is √2 times circular speed. |
Further reading
- Arthur Koestler, The Sleepwalkers (1959): the story of Copernicus, Tycho and Kepler.
- Owen Gingerich, The Eye of Heaven: Ptolemy, Copernicus, Kepler (1993).
- David L. Goodstein and Judith R. Goodstein, Feynman's Lost Lecture: The Motion of Planets Around the Sun (1996): Feynman's geometric proof that inverse-square forces give ellipses.
- Howard D. Curtis, Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students: the mathematics used by mission planners.